Urban planning community | #theplannerlife

+ Reply to thread
Results 1 to 10 of 10

Thread: Kunstler on Krier

  1. #1
          ablarc's avatar
    Registered
    Nov 2003
    Location
    East Coast
    Posts
    713

    Kunstler on Krier

    Book Review for
    The American Enterprise
    Leon Krier's
    Architecture: Choice or Fate


    Andreas Papadakis Publisher, Windsor, UK, 1998
    (Available through: National Book Network
    4729 Boston Way, Lanham, Maryland, 20706)


    Anybody who is distressed by the "fiasco of suburbia" that has become the everyday setting of American life will find illumination in Leon Krier's compelling polemic on the current state of western architecture and urbanism. Krier's message is heroically redemptive: we can choose to live in better surroundings than the universal automobile slum of our time. We don't have to remain captive victims to failed ideologies. There are enduring values in the art of building that are our natural legacy as human beings and we are free to reclaim them.

    Krier may be best known to Americans as the architect behind the Prince of Wales's new town of Poundbury in Dorset, England, and as the intellectual godfather of the New Urbanism movement in America, a campaign to rescue the landscape, townscape and civic life of our nation from the failed experiment of a drive-in utopia. Few public intellectuals in any field use the English language to more powerful effect than Krier, a Luxemburgois who lived in London for twenty years and now makes his home in southern France. He brings an exhilarating clarity to issues of place-making and architecture that have been otherwise subject to a remorseless obscurantism by a colorful cast of self-promoting avant-gardist charlatans ranging from Le Corbusier in the 1920s to Peter Eisenman in our time.

    In this comprehensive book, lavishly illustrated with the author's drawings and lucid, witty diagrams, Krier lays out his case and issues a challenge: The 20th Century belief system called Modernism, and its cultish offshoots, have failed to produce buildings and cities worth caring about, or even capable of supporting the continued enterprise of civilization, and it is time to replace them with something better, namely, traditional principles and methods of building consistent with the real needs of the human spirit. Much of the knowledge necessary to achieve this restoration of civilization's dwelling place already exists in the very history from which Modernism sought to divorce itself.

    Krier is particularly adept at presenting the meaning of the city as both a technical matter and a moral imperative.


    All traditional architecture clearly distinguishes between the public and/or sacred buildings, on the one hand, and the utilitarian and/or private buildings, on the other. The former expresses the qualities of institutions -- dignity, solemnity, grandeur for the res publica and the res sacra; the latter, the more modest private activities of housing, commerce and industry in the res privata and the res economica. . . . If museums look like factories and churches like industrial warehouses, a basic value of the state is in crisis. . . .

    Modernist dogma has promoted a confusion of building types that has made it impossible for cities to function meaningfully.

    The sterility of this so-called innovative ideology. . .
    is clearly revealed in the confusion of its terminology.
    A garden city is not a true city and not a true garden. . .
    a curtain wall is not a wall and not a curtain. . . a multi-purpose hall is no real substitute for a church, a theater, or a sportshall. The same is true of a business park, a reception area, a machine for living, a satellite city, green belts, open spaces, etc. . . .This "anti-glossary," the instrument and expression of a so-called "abstract reality," is proof that concrete urban reality is the product of a civilizing vision and not the automatic result of mere building zeal. An industry that produces non-places, unreal reality, abstract objects can only be a transitory phenomenon.

    Krier's criticism of the contemporary non-place or anti-city begins with the catastrophe of zoning -- the systematic disassembly of the complex civic organism into less than the sum of its parts. Zoning may have started as a reasonable response to the novelty of industrialism, but it has evolved into a abstract scheme which fragments daily life and makes car dependency mandatory. Under the bonehead logic of zoning, benign activities like shopping are given the same treatment as glue factories, and detached from the places where people live, with the result that we have become a United Parking Lot of America.

    To his credit, Krier recognizes that a critique of this mess is futile without a workable counter-vision, and he presents a rich one, beginning with graphical master plans for the restoration of several European city centers, a very impressive design for the "completion" of Washington, D.C., moving finally to the actual project of Poundbury which has been under construction in real bricks and mortar for a few years now, and is partially inhabited.

    Among the other putative leading figures in international architecture, Krier's work is the most comprehensive and intelligent. Least of all does he seek to shock with ersatz novelty or dazzle with fake innovative genius. The lexicon of urbanism already exists in fifty centuries of human culture. We need to reacquaint ourselves with it. The invention of the city, Krier has written elsewhere, "was a spiritual and technical achievement the historical significance of which surpassed by far the discovery of fire or the invention of the wheel." We need to reconnect our future with the past in order to live in a hopeful present. The city and the town are indispensable, and they must be places worthy of our spirits. Without them, we are liable to not remain civilized.


    --------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Jim Kunstler is the author, most recently, of
    Home From Nowhere (Simon and Schuster).

  2. #2
    Member
    Registered
    Aug 2004
    Location
    Capital District, Albany, New York
    Posts
    74
    Interesting review. My own review of the same work by Krier is currently on the APA New Planner website. Not that I am comparing myself to Kunstler!

  3. #3
          ablarc's avatar
    Registered
    Nov 2003
    Location
    East Coast
    Posts
    713
    The heart of the matter:

    Quote Originally posted by Kunstler
    Anybody who is distressed by the "fiasco of suburbia" that has become the everyday setting of American life will find illumination in Leon Krier's compelling polemic on the current state of western architecture and urbanism. Krier's message is heroically redemptive: we can choose to live in better surroundings than the universal automobile slum of our time. We don't have to remain captive victims to failed ideologies. There are enduring values in the art of building that are our natural legacy as human beings and we are free to reclaim them.

    Krier's criticism of the contemporary non-place or anti-city begins with the catastrophe of zoning -- the systematic disassembly of the complex civic organism into less than the sum of its parts. Zoning may have started as a reasonable response to the novelty of industrialism, but it has evolved into a abstract scheme which fragments daily life and makes car dependency mandatory. Under the bonehead logic of zoning, benign activities like shopping are given the same treatment as glue factories, and detached from the places where people live, with the result that we have become a United Parking Lot of America.

    The lexicon of urbanism already exists in fifty centuries of human culture. We need to reacquaint ourselves with it. The invention of the city, Krier has written elsewhere, "was a spiritual and technical achievement the historical significance of which surpassed by far the discovery of fire or the invention of the wheel." We need to reconnect our future with the past in order to live in a hopeful present. The city and the town are indispensable, and they must be places worthy of our spirits. Without them, we are liable to not remain civilized.

  4. #4
          ablarc's avatar
    Registered
    Nov 2003
    Location
    East Coast
    Posts
    713
    Quote Originally posted by RSW
    My own review of the same work by Krier is currently on the APA New Planner website.
    Why not post it?

  5. #5
          abrowne's avatar
    Registered
    Jan 2005
    Location
    BC
    Posts
    1,584
    I've been having trouble tracking this book down. My local library system (Fraser Valley Regional Libraries) does not have it. The Vancouver Public Library system does not have a copy either. My University library does, but that's not terribly useful when I'm 3 time zones away.

    The only copy I've managed to find is available from indigo/chapters for $41.26 CDN (free shipping). Any cheaper prices out there? Has anyone here bought it, and was it to your liking and satisfaction? Did anything in particular in its contents surprise you or impress you? (I find newspaper book reviews to be very hard to sit through... purple prose at its finest.)

  6. #6
          ablarc's avatar
    Registered
    Nov 2003
    Location
    East Coast
    Posts
    713
    Quote Originally posted by abrowne
    Has anyone here bought it, and was it to your liking and satisfaction? Did anything in particular in its contents surprise you or impress you? (I find newspaper book reviews to be very hard to sit through... purple prose at its finest.)
    Illustrations from it find their way into my posts from time to time (look in "Making Place and Planning Chaos"), both cartoons and those peculiarly fine ink drawings of imagined cities that put Krier on the map, first as an art gallery phenomenon and then as today's most influential urban theorist; there's no Andres Duany without Krier.

    The book contains everything you need to equip yourself for a happy lifetime of designing cities. There isn't really that much to know, if you trouble yourself to take reality seriously; just travel a lot, and look around you --like Krier himself.

    One caveat: he doesn't like skyscrapers.

    The book itself is beautiful, cover to cover, and filled with the kind of dense, exhortative prose that you can find in the Krier selection in the same post. It's a heady philosophical mix; when he speaks of the means of production, he'll remind you of the Anarchist philosopher, Kropotkin (whom I also highly recommend).

    You should be able to get it through Amazon or Amazon UK.

  7. #7
    Cyburbian AubieTurtle's avatar
    Registered
    Dec 2003
    Location
    Downtown Atlanta
    Posts
    894
    Quote Originally posted by abrowne
    I've been having trouble tracking this book down. My local library system (Fraser Valley Regional Libraries) does not have it. The Vancouver Public Library system does not have a copy either. My University library does, but that's not terribly useful when I'm 3 time zones away.

    The only copy I've managed to find is available from indigo/chapters for $41.26 CDN (free shipping). Any cheaper prices out there? Has anyone here bought it, and was it to your liking and satisfaction? Did anything in particular in its contents surprise you or impress you? (I find newspaper book reviews to be very hard to sit through... purple prose at its finest.)
    From the FVRL site:

    How do I get books or other items that arenít listed in your library catalogue?
    If the item is older than 12 months, you can request it on interlibrary loan. Youíll find more information on interlibrary loans here. Books published within the last 12 months cannot be requested through interlibrary loans.


    Interlibrary loans usually take a week or two for the material to come in (depends on which library your library borrows it from) but in general it works out well.

  8. #8
          abrowne's avatar
    Registered
    Jan 2005
    Location
    BC
    Posts
    1,584
    Haha, thank you for acquainting me with my own library system. No sarcasm intended. I'll give that a try. I've not dealt with anything but my university's library in quite some time (which has yet to disappoint).
    Last edited by abrowne; 06 Jul 2005 at 1:38 AM.

  9. #9
    Cyburbian AubieTurtle's avatar
    Registered
    Dec 2003
    Location
    Downtown Atlanta
    Posts
    894
    Interlibrary loans are one of the worst publicized services in the library world. Almost every library is part of the network but very few do much to let their patrons know about it. I don't know if it is a territorial thing, ego, or maybe just a lack of a good way to get the message out (do you put up a big banner over the circulation desk?).

  10. #10
          abrowne's avatar
    Registered
    Jan 2005
    Location
    BC
    Posts
    1,584
    Quote Originally posted by AubieTurtle
    Interlibrary loans are one of the worst publicized services in the library world. Almost every library is part of the network but very few do much to let their patrons know about it. I don't know if it is a territorial thing, ego, or maybe just a lack of a good way to get the message out (do you put up a big banner over the circulation desk?).
    I've put in ILL requests with both the FVRL and the VPL - we'll see what happens. Apparently it would be a miracle if I were to see it within four weeks. Usual turnaround is six to eight weeks, shockingly. More likely than not I will cave and simply purchase the book before then.

    As for why the services are not publicized, I can only imagine that it is rather costly and libraries would prefer volume to remain low.

    http://www.chapters.indigo.ca/item.a...n=books&zxac=1
    link to chapters/indigo store page for book
    Last edited by abrowne; 06 Jul 2005 at 3:48 AM.

+ Reply to thread

More at Cyburbia

  1. Ask James Howard Kunstler
    Make No Small Plans
    Replies: 15
    Last post: 17 May 2008, 7:43 PM
  2. Replies: 2
    Last post: 01 Aug 2005, 4:01 PM
  3. Replies: 17
    Last post: 13 Oct 2004, 10:07 PM
  4. Holiday Kunstler
    Friday Afternoon Club
    Replies: 19
    Last post: 23 Dec 2003, 6:11 PM
  5. Another Kunstler Rant
    Friday Afternoon Club
    Replies: 13
    Last post: 02 Oct 2003, 10:43 AM