-
Cyburbia is a friendly big tent, where we share our experiences and thoughts about urban planning practice, the built environment, planning adjacent topics, and anything else that comes to mind. No ads, no spam, and it's free. It's easy to join!
For me Planning is...
- Thread starter el Guapo
- Start date
- Status
Planderella
Cyburbian
- Messages
- 5,344
- Points
- 31
Okay El Guapo....what can I say? You tapped into my destructive side with this poll. 
Big Easy King
Cyburbian
- Messages
- 1,358
- Points
- 23
...effective development and growth while protecting neighborhoods. I haven't seen this ideal situation yet, but I can still dream. ;-)
Zoning Goddess
Cyburbian
- Messages
- 13,843
- Points
- 40
I'm in a love/hate relationship, too. Love what I'm doing now. Loved zoning/land use. Hated political end of it. Hated the paperwork/late night meetings and lying, a$$-kissing lawyers.
- Messages
- 15,937
- Points
- 60
biscuit said:
DITTOS
I am still relatively new to the profession, but I already feel it starting to beat me down. I really am not a fan of "current planning". I am too much of a "big picture" person to stay in current planning for much longer.
But I'll see how I feel in a couple more years.
- Messages
- 12,008
- Points
- 52
Love / Hate
Definitely love/hate at this juncture. Love it when we say something has to be done a certain way -- over objections -- and it gets done that way. Then people say "you know, you guys were right".
Hate the political environment (especially with Mayoral election just weeks away). We are seriously a-political in the office and in our personal lives, but that's all people want to talk about. This is my fourth election and by far the meanest yet.
I've been considering starting my own little shop if things turn out badly. Scary -- no insurance, no bennies, and no client list. On the other hand, I get to be the boss.
Definitely love/hate at this juncture. Love it when we say something has to be done a certain way -- over objections -- and it gets done that way. Then people say "you know, you guys were right".
Hate the political environment (especially with Mayoral election just weeks away). We are seriously a-political in the office and in our personal lives, but that's all people want to talk about. This is my fourth election and by far the meanest yet.
I've been considering starting my own little shop if things turn out badly. Scary -- no insurance, no bennies, and no client list. On the other hand, I get to be the boss.
It was difficult for me to pick from these choices, given that I fall "in between."
Frankly, cities and architecture fascinate me, and I could never work in job, say, as a lawyer, or a "marketing professional" engaged in selling widgets to the world.
Am I excited about my current professional status? Not as much. I really like my coworkers, my bosses, and the organization I work for. I am paid fairly, the work is diverse and always changing, and I have good work-life balance. So, I ain't complaining.
I have less liking for the suburban town where I work, frankly. I am not always that engaged with the issues we face, and I thoroughly dislike some of the NIMBYism that we, as aplanners all face.
Despite my rather sharp rebukes to Super Amputee cat, I have to admit that I share his feeling of deeper malaise about current social, economic, and architecture trends. A suburban landscape of parking lots, giant outlet stores and Super Wal Marts really bothers me. But, that is not the Planning profession per se, that is "The World's Highest Standard of Living" at work, and I have no solutions nor would I suggest that "more planning" or "more regulations" are any solution. I sometimes believe the whole edifice will collapse of its own accord someday. Thankfully, I have no kids, because I don't know what kind of world they will be facing.
Boy, am I gloomy and wordy.
Frankly, cities and architecture fascinate me, and I could never work in job, say, as a lawyer, or a "marketing professional" engaged in selling widgets to the world.
Am I excited about my current professional status? Not as much. I really like my coworkers, my bosses, and the organization I work for. I am paid fairly, the work is diverse and always changing, and I have good work-life balance. So, I ain't complaining.
I have less liking for the suburban town where I work, frankly. I am not always that engaged with the issues we face, and I thoroughly dislike some of the NIMBYism that we, as aplanners all face.
Despite my rather sharp rebukes to Super Amputee cat, I have to admit that I share his feeling of deeper malaise about current social, economic, and architecture trends. A suburban landscape of parking lots, giant outlet stores and Super Wal Marts really bothers me. But, that is not the Planning profession per se, that is "The World's Highest Standard of Living" at work, and I have no solutions nor would I suggest that "more planning" or "more regulations" are any solution. I sometimes believe the whole edifice will collapse of its own accord someday. Thankfully, I have no kids, because I don't know what kind of world they will be facing.
Boy, am I gloomy and wordy.
Last edited:
Richmond Jake
You can't fight in here. This is the War Room!
- Messages
- 18,300
- Points
- 45
It's just a job to me. I lost my idealism and passion for the profession long ago...the politics, the approval of bad projects and having to compromise my positions too many times have left a bitter taste in my mouth.
Love/Hate
I love the greater profession and the issues it deals with but I hate the beaurocratic aspects of what I do. I don't feel that I MUST be a planner forever. I'll always be interested in the urban environment etc. no matter what I do for a living. Sometimes I fantasize about going back to school for something else that can compliment my education and experience so far - but you can only spend so much time learning, especially with kids.
I love the greater profession and the issues it deals with but I hate the beaurocratic aspects of what I do. I don't feel that I MUST be a planner forever. I'll always be interested in the urban environment etc. no matter what I do for a living. Sometimes I fantasize about going back to school for something else that can compliment my education and experience so far - but you can only spend so much time learning, especially with kids.
- Messages
- 15,937
- Points
- 60
I also want to "DITTOS" for BKM's response.
I love the development and history of the built environment (it is inextricably [sp?] tied into everything else in our society. It is the physical manifestation of our society).
But I have an unfortunate disconnect when trying the see the importance of processing an annoying pool variation, or trying to explain to people that their thirty year old subdivision is a dynamic (sub) urban environment and change is inevitable, but they don't get it, and still don't come to the variation hearing. 'Your neighbor is going to put that big addition on their house, because they can.'
But I have also gotten to do some real planning recently. I volunteered through APA-Chicago Metro Section's Pro Bono program, and did a visioning session with a small muni. that didn't have any professional planning staff.
It was amazing. I think it ruined my present position for me, because long range planning is an order of magnitude better than plan review.
I love the development and history of the built environment (it is inextricably [sp?] tied into everything else in our society. It is the physical manifestation of our society).
But I have an unfortunate disconnect when trying the see the importance of processing an annoying pool variation, or trying to explain to people that their thirty year old subdivision is a dynamic (sub) urban environment and change is inevitable, but they don't get it, and still don't come to the variation hearing. 'Your neighbor is going to put that big addition on their house, because they can.'
But I have also gotten to do some real planning recently. I volunteered through APA-Chicago Metro Section's Pro Bono program, and did a visioning session with a small muni. that didn't have any professional planning staff.
It was amazing. I think it ruined my present position for me, because long range planning is an order of magnitude better than plan review.
Rumpy Tunanator
Cyburbian
- Messages
- 4,463
- Points
- 25
Re: For me Planning is....
-You wouldn't be refering to that wheeling and dealing traveling salesman, Satan, would you?
Planning, all glory and no recongition
moose said:
-You wouldn't be refering to that wheeling and dealing traveling salesman, Satan, would you?
Planning, all glory and no recongition
Duke Of Dystopia
Cyburbian
- Messages
- 2,699
- Points
- 24
biscuit said:Perhaps it would be a good idea to cut back your intake of goth inspired, symphonic Finnish death metal.
THATS TOO FAR FOR ANYONE DARK AT HEART TO DO!
steveanne
Member
- Messages
- 176
- Points
- 7
So ummmm....
I came to love planning too late in my life to actually work as a planner. I minored in geography. That was about as close as I got. So, now I work in purcashing in the corporate office of a major Rx chain, and I log on to Cyburbia to get all the latest developments in cities throughout the US and Canada. I am a planner-wanna-be. I play Sim City, I draw maps, I read the census for fun, I compare cities, I get excited when something new is announced to be built, and get disappointed when it is a used car lot, I draw light rail routes on my local maps, I take pictures of architecture I like, I use words like TIF, brownfield, and mixed-use and no one understands me. I get angry at folks that cry NIMBY, and write down lists of what a city's center needs to get it back to being a 24-hour downtown.
But... Instead I purchase stuff. (sigh)
I came to love planning too late in my life to actually work as a planner. I minored in geography. That was about as close as I got. So, now I work in purcashing in the corporate office of a major Rx chain, and I log on to Cyburbia to get all the latest developments in cities throughout the US and Canada. I am a planner-wanna-be. I play Sim City, I draw maps, I read the census for fun, I compare cities, I get excited when something new is announced to be built, and get disappointed when it is a used car lot, I draw light rail routes on my local maps, I take pictures of architecture I like, I use words like TIF, brownfield, and mixed-use and no one understands me. I get angry at folks that cry NIMBY, and write down lists of what a city's center needs to get it back to being a 24-hour downtown.
But... Instead I purchase stuff. (sigh)
The Irish One
Member
- Messages
- 2,266
- Points
- 25
For me Planning is... " a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma."
One of my best buds who managed a sister Main Street with me a few years back said it best when she was encouraging me to go back to school rather then find another community development position,
"You are a planner and that's all there is to it. You could get another community position job but you'll still be a planner."
Shortly thereafter I turned in my application for grad school. In the words of Popeye, "I Yam what I Yam".
"You are a planner and that's all there is to it. You could get another community position job but you'll still be a planner."
Shortly thereafter I turned in my application for grad school. In the words of Popeye, "I Yam what I Yam".
- Messages
- 10,156
- Points
- 45
At this very moment....work is hell. Secretary is out indefinitely after an accident, IT guy is on vaca (guess who his backup is?), and my plate is overflowing. My week ended last week with the finance director telling me if her computer wasn't fixed, no one was getting paid this week. Spent the better part of 6 hours working on her computer in between meetings with applicants and engineers.
I still, for the most part, can't picture myself doing anything else. I love this stuff.
I still, for the most part, can't picture myself doing anything else. I love this stuff.
The Irish One
Member
- Messages
- 2,266
- Points
- 25
One word for you, ethic!
BKM said:Hey, many planners are "wannabe architects."
No design talent or drawing ability whatsoever.
So instead, I purchase "architectural" furniture, read Dwell magazine, and all that
Yuppie am I
This is me to a 'T'. Especailly the 'wanna be' part. As I'm still a starry eyed Graduate Student, not yet employed, I have this urge to call the profession the holy grail. I know that with in 3 years I'll be bitter and grumpy, possibly becoming a vengefull bastard, but I've still got three years of joy to come!
- Status