• We're a fun, friendly, and diverse group of planners, placemakers, students, and other folks who found their people here. Create your FREE Cyburbia ID, and join us today! Use your email address, or register through your Facebook, Google, Twitter, or Microsoft account.
  • On Thursday night (2/21), I did something I probably shouldn't have with the server. I lost about 90 posts and three new users in the process. If you registered on Thursday, please re-register. If you posted on Thursday, maybe post twice as much on Friday? Again, I apologize. :(

Is it legal to completely prohibit ...

Dan

Dear Leader
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
17,042
Points
49
Day labor centers?
Pawn shops?
Roadside vendors?
Truck stops and travel centers?
Mobile home sales?
Recreational vehicle sales?
Heavy equipment sales and rental?
Auto auctions?
Plasma centers?
 

giff57

Corn Burning Fool
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
5,378
Points
31
The way I understand the case law...I don't think you can completely prohibit anything (provided that the activity is not already illegal). If it is a legitimate business, you can regulate it, but not ban it.
 

Dan

Dear Leader
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
17,042
Points
49
giff57 said:
The way I understand the case law...I don't think you can completely prohibit anything (provided that the activity is not already illegal). If it is a legitimate business, you can regulate it, but not ban it.
I've heard that too -- but how does that explain municipalities with no non-residential zoning, or with no heavy industry? I know you can't ban sexually oriented or CMRS facilities. However, if some municipalities don't have provisions for oil refineries, glue factories or smelters in their zoning codes, the logic seems to be that some other "legitimate businesses" can be banned.
 

giff57

Corn Burning Fool
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
5,378
Points
31
Re: Re: Is it legal to completely prohibit ...

Dan Tasman said:


However, if some municipalities don't have provisions for oil refineries, glue factories or smelters in their zoning codes, the logic seems to be that some other "legitimate businesses" can be banned.
Sticking with my way of thinking about it, it is probably because they have not been challenged. Another reason the Adult uses are different is there is no "freedom of speech" issue in siting a glue factory. It is easier for those type of uses to go to a city that has already zoned its poor minority neighborhoods to heavy industrial.
 

Richmond Jake

Cyburbian
Messages
18,168
Points
41
Things are clearly different outside of California--in each jurisdication that I have worked, if the use was not listed as allowed as a matter of right or allowed subject to the approval of a conditional use permit, the use was prohibited. For instance, nuclear power plants were not listed in the zoning ordinances of two of my former working environments so we concluded they were not permitted.
 

IPlan?

Cyburbian
Messages
60
Points
4
The way I see it, if a use is not listed and permitted as of right, it is not necessarly prohibited. What it means is that the use, once proposed on a parcel, will have to be addressed on its own merits for appropriateness. Then one basically ends up with a site specific situation. Unless it is written somewhere that it is not permitted, there is still an opportunity to to introduce the use.
 

NHPlanner

Forums Administrator & Gallery Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
9,843
Points
37
Permissive or Restrictive Zoning?

My read of zoning ordinances is that there a 3 types:

Permissive: Lists all uses permitted, and those not permitted (by right, Conditional Use, Special Exception) are prohibited.

Restrictive: Lists all uses not permitted, all those not listed are permitted.

Hybrid: A combination of uses permitted and prohibited are listed....making interpretation of the ordinance a nightmare. :)
 
Top