• Ongoing coronavirus / COVID-19 discussion: how is the pandemic affecting your community, workplace, and wellness? 🦠

    Working from home? So are we. Come join us! Cyburbia is a friendly big tent, where we share our experiences and thoughts about urban planning practice, planning adjacent topics, and whatever else comes to mind. No ads, no spam, no social distancing.

Jane Jacobs' Neighborhood: Hudson Street (photos and commentary)

ablarc

Cyburbian Emeritus
Messages
713
Points
20
Moderator note:

(Dan) 19 October 2009: Images now hosted in the Cyburbia Gallery. See http://www.cyburbia.org/gallery/showgallery.php/cat/6514



JANE JACOBS’ NEIGHBORHOOD


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_00.jpg

Mythic Hudson Street! America’s favorite urban ‘hood!

On Hudson Street, Jane Jacobs wrote The Death and Life of Great American Cities about her beloved West Village neighborhood. She almost sold Americans on urban living.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_01.jpg

Still a mixed neighborhood, but less than then.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_02.jpg

Today, yuppies and gays are the dominant groups.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_03.jpg

Fourth Street at Sheridan Square. Complex urban space makes a crossroads.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_04.jpg

Relics of old Bohemia, as in the Latin Quarter.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_05.jpg

Synagogue: superimposed Greek temples on a house lot.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_06.jpg

Beatniks and kids persist, but in reduced numbers.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_07.jpg

New Yorkers are generally, but not always, in better shape than suburbanites.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_08.jpg

West 11th at West 4th: to see how this intersection is possible, consult the map.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_08a.gif

An irregular grid. The Village predates the Commissioners’ Plan (1811), whereby Manhattan acquired its rigid grid.

Jacobs’ West Village is bounded by Seventh Avenue, 14th Street, West Street and Houston Street. Its main street is Hudson Street. It has short blocks.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_09.jpg

Many intersections are not at right angles.

Sparely populated suburbs may look appealing, said Jacobs, but without an active sidewalk life, without the frequent, serendipitous interactions of many different people, "there is no public acquaintanceship, no foundation of public trust, no cross-connections with the necessary people--and no practice or ease in applying the most ordinary techniques of city public life at lowly levels."

"It is possible in a city street neighborhood to know all kinds of people without unwelcome entanglements, without boredom, necessity for excuses, explanations, fears of giving offense, embarrassments respecting impositions or commitments, and all such paraphernalia of obligations which can accompany less limited relationships,"

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_11.jpg

Acquaintances.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_12.jpg

Extra Virgin on Fourth Street. Commercial mixed with residential throughout.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_13.jpg

Tenements on Bank Street, some missing cornices.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_13a.jpg

Perry Street: newly famous for Meier buildings, down by the riverside.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_14.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_15.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_16.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_17.jpg


”Jacobs argued that when a neighborhood is oriented toward the street, when sidewalks are used for socializing and play and commerce, the users of that street are transformed by the resulting stimulation: they form relationships and casual contacts they would never have otherwise.” –-Malcolm Gladwell

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_18.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_19.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_20.jpg


The West Village, Jacobs pointed out, was blessed with a mixture of houses and apartments and shops and offices and industry, which meant that there were always people "outdoors on different schedules and... in the place for different purposes."

“The idea is to exchange private space for public space, where residents agree to live in tiny apartments in exchange for a wealth of nearby cafés and stores and bars and parks. The West Village forces its residents outdoors.” –-M.G.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_21.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_22.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_23.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_24.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_25.jpg

Tall buildings generally indicate one of the numbered avenues thrust through the Village in the Twenties to connect Midtown with Downtown. These avenues are too wide; they function as speedways and somewhat fragment the Village.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_26.jpg

Fanciful Twenties apartments. A man’s home is his…

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_27.jpg

Sober brownstones, one awaiting a buyer with a few million.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_28.jpg

Abrupt scale change at Eighth Avenue. Aircraft carrier looms. A cornucopia of styles.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_29.jpg

Belgian restaurant, Belgian building.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_30.jpg

Two oldtimers share a fire escape.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_31.jpg

An elegant late Federal doorway influenced by Robert Adam.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_32.jpg

Abingdon Square, a Hudson Street oasis: the West Village’s central square. Park as living room, park as study.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_33.jpg

Park as nursery.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_34.jpg

Park as bedroom.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_35.jpg

Park as dining room.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_37.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_38.jpg

Hudson Street

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_39.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_40.jpg

Approaching the fabled White Horse.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_41.jpg

The White Horse Tavern, where Dylan Thomas drank himself to death. Now mobbed by tourists, for whom outdoor tables are set up. There were none for the windy boy and a bit.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_42.jpg

There’s even room for overflow, across the street.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_43.jpg

Inside also the tourists teem. The guy with the paper couldn’t care less. Must be a regular; does this every Saturday, tourists or not.

Jacobs rhapsodizes the White Horse of yore: home to longshoremen and writers and intellectuals--a place where, on a winter's night, “as the doors open, a solid wave of conversation and animation surges out and hits you."

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_44.jpg

In the north, Hudson terminates at 14th Street. Here begins the Meatpacking District, New York’s current hot find. On weekdays, the sidewalks still run with blood till 8 am, but less than before. The rest of the day, they run with Rolling Rock.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_45.jpg

The view from Markt, a big old Belgian brasserie noted for its mussels and its pick-up bar. Diagonally across Fourteenth they have added three stories to an old building.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_46.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_47.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_48.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_49.jpg

Greenwich Avenue, Eighth Avenue and Fourteenth Street converge in a most Parisian manner, complete with flatirons.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_50.jpg

More Paris: wet cobbles, slick boutiques, frameless glass and woven café furniture. The cab tells you it’s New York.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_51.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_52.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_53.jpg

Paris again, this time the Sixteenth, complete with graffiti.



jane_jacobs_neighborhood_55.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_56.jpg

If you park here, you might encounter Nicole Kidman. She lives right next door…

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_57.jpg

…here…

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_58.jpg

…along with Ralph Lauren and Martha Stewart—no, she is temporarily residing elsewhere.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_59.jpg

A stack of celebrities wrapped in glass by Richard Meier.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_60.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_61.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_62.jpg

Silver gloss extends to lobby.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_63.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_64.jpg

He does not appear able to design an ugly building.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_65.jpg

The trend is to riverview living. Need at least a BMW for that.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_66.jpg

No wonder!: across West Street and the Hudson, the Jersey City skyline beckons. Jersey City??

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_67.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_68.jpg

Jersey City? Wasn’t even there last decade. Now it’s like Houston or Hong Kong in a distorting mirror. The big, sinister tower at left is by Cesar Pelli. He has one like it in Hong Kong, only twice as high. And you should see the view when the cruise ships glide down the river. That’s when my camera batteries gave out.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_69.jpg

Manhattan view is not so shabby either, though missing a pair of famous buildings.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_70.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_71.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_72.jpg

Turf on pier is plastic.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_73.jpg

Saturday, the day before the Gay Pride Parade, the boys were out and swarming.

“Jane Jacobs did not win the battle she set out to fight. The West Village remains an anomaly. Most developers did not want to build the kind of community Jacobs talked about, and most Americans didn't want to live in one.” –Malcolm Gladwell.

There are exceptions:

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_74.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_75.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_76.jpg

New old town house.

From a curious article on -–of all things— the theory of office landscape:

Designs For Working

Copyright 2000, Malcolm Gladwell

Why your bosses want to turn your new office into Greenwich Village

"The Death and Life of Great American Cities" was a controversial book, largely because there was always a whiff of paternalism in Jacobs's vision of what city life ought to be.

Chelsea--the neighborhood directly to the north of her beloved West Village--had "mixtures and types of buildings and densities of dwelling units per acre... almost identical with those of Greenwich Village," she noted. But its long-predicted renaissance would never happen, she maintained, because of the "barriers of long, self-isolating blocks."

She hated Chatham Village, a planned "garden city" development in Pittsburgh. It was a picturesque green enclave, but it suffered, in Jacobs's analysis, from a lack of sidewalk life.

She wasn't concerned that some people might not want an active street life in their neighborhood; that what she saw as the "self-isolating blocks" of Chelsea others would see as a welcome respite from the bustle of the city, or that Chatham Village would appeal to some people precisely because one did not encounter on its sidewalks a "solid wave of conversation and animation." Jacobs felt that city dwellers belonged in environments like the West Village, whether they realized it or not.

Human behavior, after all, is shaped by context, but how it is shaped--and whether we'll be happy with the result--we can understand only with experience. Jane Jacobs knew the virtues of the West Village because she lived there.

What she couldn't know was that her ideas about community would ultimately make more sense in the workplace. From time to time, social critics have bemoaned the falling rates of community participation in American life, but they have made the same mistake.

The reason Americans are content to bowl alone (or, for that matter, not bowl at all) is that, increasingly, they receive all the social support they need--all the serendipitous interactions that serve to make them happy and productive--from nine to five.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_77.jpg

The Make.

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_78.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_79.jpg


jane_jacobs_neighborhood_80.jpg

Village landmark: Jefferson Library.
 
Last edited:

BKM

Cyburbian
Messages
6,463
Points
29
You are the king of the philosophical photo post, ablarc. This may be my favorite.
 

gct13

Cyburbian
Messages
51
Points
4
ablarc I may have bumped into you the other day, I was taking the same walk about the same time. Thank you for yet another epic thread!

Slight correction-

Greenwich Avenue, Eighth Avenue and Fourteenth Street converge in a most Parisian manner, complete with flatirons.
This is 14th Street at Hudson St & Ninth Ave.



Fantastic buildings. What sort of space-age soundproofing do you thing they applied to muffle the 6-lane roar of West St. directly below?
 

Budgie

Cyburbian
Messages
5,270
Points
30
I thoroughly enjoy Ablarc's presentation. My only comment is that the rampant urban foliage is disturbing the "eyes on the street". I bet the birds deficating on the cars gets a little old. Supplant the trees to the neighborhood park.
 

ablarc

Cyburbian Emeritus
Messages
713
Points
20
That's right, GCT13, Ninth Avenue. Thanks for the correction. Would love to see your pics.
 
Messages
1,264
Points
22
This post makes me NYC thirsty. I'll have to quench that thirst in a couple of weeks, when I go up there for a wedding. Can anyone recommend any jazz clubs to go to on a Friday? The Blue Note and Village Vanguard are very pricey.
 

JNA

Cyburbian Plus
Messages
26,334
Points
67
Good Composition, Excellent Effort.

BTW
Q. What kinda of camera are you using?
 

ablarc

Cyburbian Emeritus
Messages
713
Points
20
Camera

Minolta Z1 3.2megapixel. It's like an extension of your hand. Let's you take a picture with one hand. No squinting, no fiddling. All controls fall to your thumb or forefinger. Helps to be right-handed. There's a 4.0 version out now.
 

biscuit

Cyburbian
Messages
3,904
Points
25
ablarc said:
Minolta Z1 3.2megapixel. It's like an extension of your hand. Let's you take a picture with one hand. No squinting, no fiddling. All controls fall to your thumb or forefinger. Helps to be right-handed. There's a 4.0 version out now.

You answered my question before I could ask it.

I have thoroughly enjoyed your photo essays and am even inspired to do a few of my own. Perhaps I'll start with a tour of Chatham Village...just to prove that Jane Jacobs was/is wrong to hate it. :)
 
Last edited:

Tranplanner

maudit anglais
Messages
7,935
Points
37
Awesome stuff - I should take a stroll through J.J.'s current 'hood and take some pics for comparison. Similar, but definitely lower-scale!
 

stroskey

Cyburbian
Messages
1,212
Points
17
Interesting! As someone who has never been to NYC I always pictured Manhattan more like this...

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_49.jpg


than this...

jane_jacobs_neighborhood_22.jpg
 
Top