• Cyburbia is a friendly big tent, where we share our experiences and thoughts about urban planning practice, planning adjacent topics, and whatever else comes to mind. No ads, no spam, no echo chambers. Create your FREE Cyburbia ID, and join us today! You can also register through your Reddit, Facebook, Google, Twitter, or Microsoft account.

new approach in prison design

ten

Member
Messages
6
Points
0
hi guys,
got anything about prison design? like a new design approach, maybe eco-friendly kinda approach...or something like visitor-friendly...or anything.

i'm limited to checking out old dilapidated prison/city jails /penitentiaries locally, nothing much out of them except problems of overcrowing, etc...which is why i'm looking into this as a possible arch'l research.

i'd appreciate any suggestion, comment or even a crazy idea...

Thanks.:army
 

GeogPlanner

Cyburbian
Messages
1,433
Points
25
i'm partial to the neo-dungeon movement...a rebirth of the dark, dank medival dungeon with parking in the rear to accomidate cars.

rack optional.
 

Cardinal

Cyburbian
Messages
10,080
Points
34
GeogPlanner has an interesting approach. Air space might otherwise be used for property tax-paying development (most likely industrial) is wasted on prisons. House them underground. The more constant temperature of an underground location could reduce heating and cooling costs. For the most part, cells don't have windows anyway. You could develop the above ground portion of the site for other uses. I do agree, though, put the parking in the rear.

The full dungeon approach - multiple prisoners chained to the wall, torture, etc. has merit in that it allows more opportunities to socialize with other prisoners and the guards. Rats can make a good pet for the prisoners. But These are more sociological issues than planning ones.
 

Jeff

Cyburbian
Messages
4,161
Points
27
I myself prefer the models without cable TV and weightlifting equipment.

I am also more in favor of the iron/steel/cement architectural design as opposed to the neo traditional vinyl siding and OSB board.

:)
 

Runner

Cyburbian
Messages
566
Points
17
ten,

I don't think that we are capable of giving good advise on this topic from here in the USofA. We have too many lawyers and too many prisoners "rights" to ever be effective in this field...
:(

Take for example the killer of the little girl on the loose in California right now. When he gets caught we will force him to live in a fully air conditioned and heated facility with full medical and dental care including cosmetic surgery as desired, provide a full college education, cable TV, religious services, meals prepared as he prefers (if he wants crunchy peanut butter he will be provided that too), and if he does not want to work he will not have to... After all, he has "rights"

Rrrrrrrrr, sorry rant...

Seems to me the French had some good eco-friendly prisons at one time, maybe in French Guiana...
 

ten

Member
Messages
6
Points
0
underground

Michael Stumpf said:
House them underground. The more constant temperature of an underground location could reduce heating and cooling costs. For the most part, cells don't have windows anyway.
The full dungeon approach - multiple prisoners chained to the wall, torture, etc. has merit in that it allows more opportunities to socialize with other prisoners and the guards. Rats can make a good pet for the prisoners. But These are more sociological issues than planning ones.
you got radical ideas...i like it. i was also thinking of the dungeon-inspired approach too, but it seems "too punishing" (i need to define this, i know) rather than "rehabilitating" criminals..and the socializing aspect would be challenging...hmmm.

yep. maybe its enough that they be confined to a "dug in" 25 ft deep or-so-complex, with maximum security cells dug even deeper underground with "just enough" air passage from ducts or something like it...? what do you think? is it possible?

thanks! your ideas triggered my brainwaves to the max. i'll try to beef -up this idea...keep them coming...
 

donk

Cyburbian
Messages
6,970
Points
30
The idea of punishing is interesting. Paraphrasing what Lazarus Long said "if its not cruel and unusual, then its not punishment"
 
Top