• Cyburbia is a friendly big tent, where we share our experiences and thoughts about urban planning practice, planning adjacent topics, and whatever else comes to mind. No ads, no spam, no echo chambers. Create your FREE Cyburbia ID, and join us today! You can also register through your Reddit, Facebook, Google, Twitter, or Microsoft account.

New York in Black and White (photos and commentary)

ablarc

Cyburbian Emeritus
Messages
713
Points
20
Moderator note:

(Dan) 11 October 2009: Images now hosted in the Cyburbia Gallery. See http://www.cyburbia.org/gallery/showgallery.php/cat/6529


NEW YORK IN BLACK AND WHITE

0011.jpg
Woolworth

0021.jpg
West St., 1885


Herald Sq., 1888. 6th Ave. El.

0051.jpg
Terminal, 1892. Alfred Stieglitz.

0061.jpg
Winter, 1893. Stieglitz.

0071.jpg
Broadway, 1894

0081.jpg
Herald Sq., 1895


Lower Broadway, 1899. Lots of hats.

0101.jpg
Police Parade, 1899. Bowler hats, hardly any women.


Tiffany’s, Union Sq., 1899. Early car and some figures added by artist.

0121.jpg
Getting a ticket, 1900

0131.jpg
Easter, Fifth Avenue, 1900.One car visible, coming towards foreground.

0141.jpg
Hester St., Lower East Side, 1901.

0151.jpg
Flatiron, 1903. Burnham.

0161.jpg
Broad St., 1904. Stock Exchange and Federal Hall.

0171.jpg
Municipal Building under construction, 1904. McKim. No cars.

0181.jpg
The Belmont Coach, 1905, four horses. Dogs run free.

0191.jpg
Easter, Fifth Ave., 1906. No cars.

0201.jpg
City Hall subway, 1907. Turkish headhouses.

0214.jpg
Lower East Side, 1908.

0221.jpg
Herald Square, 1909. Skyscraper beyond is NY Times Building in Times Sq. Cars have replaced horses.

0231.jpg
Automatic Vaudeville, Union Sq., 1910.

0241.jpg
Downtown skyline with Singer Building., 1910. World’s tallest.

0251.jpg
Downtown skyline with Woolworth Building., 1913. World’s tallest.

0261.jpg
Birdseye, 1913, with artist’s enhancement. Hand colored.

0271.jpg
Federal Crowd Control, 1918. Machine guns in front, modified phalanx. Soldiers on sides assigned to upstairs windows. Wilson feared antiwar riots, losing mind to small strokes.

0281.jpg
Times Square from New York Times Building., 1922.

0291.jpg
HMS Leviathan and Singer Building., 1923.

0301.jpg
Fifth Ave., 1924. Buses and taxis on parade.

0319.jpg
Coney Island, 1928. Walker Evans.

0321.jpg
Lower Broadway Tickertape, 1928. For Bremen crew, first east-west transatlantic flight.

0331.jpg
1928. Three biggest spires not yet built. Fairchild Aerial Surveys.

0341.jpg
1935 Philadelphia, just for fun. Skyscraper density nearly matched New York’s. Fairchild.

0351.jpg
Chrysler Gargoyle, 1929.

0361.jpg
42nd Street, 1929. Walker Evans.

0371.jpg
Building the Empire State, 1930. Lewis Hine.

0381.jpg
Icarus, 1930. Hine.

0391.jpg
Liberty, 1930. With symbols.

0401.jpg
1931. Fairchild.

0417.jpg
Midtown, 1931. The tracks lead to Penn Station. Post Office spans tracks, may some day be Penn Station. Fairchild.

0421.jpg
Sikorsky Clipper, 1931. New spires gleam. River traffic, piers, ocean liner in slip.

0431.jpg
Midtown’s lineup of spires with sky in between, 1931.

0441.jpg
Six engines! 1931.

0451.jpg
The valley between, 1931

0471.jpg
Spires of Gotham, 1932

0481.jpg
Tropical Drinks Five Cents, 1932

0491.jpg
Subway execs inspect new subway car, 1933. Breakthrough blowers ventilate with windows closed! Cane seats.

0501.jpg
Columbus Circle, 1933. No Time-Warner, no Trump International, no Venetian palazzetto.

0511.jpg
Just $24 in1626? More than that in 1933.

0521.jpg
Three-point perspective, 1934.

Berenice Abbott photos, 1935

0531.jpg
Chambers at Oak. Horse-drawn wagon.

0541.jpg
Bowery.

0551.jpg
Henry St. Beyond, Towers of Zenith loom in the mist.

0561.jpg
Mad King Ludwig in Greenwich Village: Jeferson Market, then Jefferson Courthouse, now Jefferson Library, 6th Avenue.

0571.jpg
Murray Hill Hotel with fancy fire escape.

0581.jpg
Cities Service Tower. Horse-drawn wagons lingered into the mid-sixties.

059.jpg
Prickly skyline with famous bridge, 1935.

060.jpg
Times Square, 1935. Betty Boop on the marquee. The Astor came down mid-sixties, along with Penn Station and Singer Building: a bad time for beaux-arts. Streetcars in the square, no overhead wires.

0611.jpg
Times Square looking South to Times Building. Mid-sixties this was stripped to steel skeleton and re-clothed in kitsch marble by mod illustrator Peter Max. More bad times for beaux-arts.

Berenice Abbott photos, 1936

0621.jpg
The El featured potbellied stoves.

0631.jpg
Fifth Avenue bus in Washington Square.

0641.jpg
Dapper in front of Dock Department.

0651.jpg
Billie’s Bar, First Ave. at 56th.

066.jpg
Bowery and Doyer. 3rd Ave. El.

067.jpg
Christopher and Bleecker. A wood-clad survivor.

068.jpg
Church of God, E. 132nd St.

069.jpg
Ferry, Chambers St.

070.jpg
Greyhound and Penn Station.

0711.jpg
Herald Sq. Chain-drive trucks also survived into the sixties.

0721.jpg
Manhattan Bridge.


Milk Truck, Greenwich Village.

0741.jpg
Newspaper (Park) Row. Center building once tallest. Berenice Abbott.

0761.jpg
At Hudson River terminus of Cortlandt St., motorized and horse-drawn vans transferred goods to and from barge-borne railcars.

0771.jpg
Pike and Henry, Lower East Side, with Manhattan Bridge and a horse.

079.jpg
S. Klein On-The-Square, Union Sq. Contraposto.

078.jpg
Union Square with Turkish subway kiosk. Is that man using a cellphone??

080.jpg
Magnificent Manhattan spires from Willow and Poplar, Brooklyn. Cathedrals of Commerce.

Berenice Abbott photos, 1937

0821.jpg
Avenue D and 10th St. Chain-drive truck.

0831.jpg
Hester Street.

0841.jpg
Riverside Drive Viaduct. .

0851.jpg
Oyster House, South Street, under Manhattan Bridge, with pile of oyster shells.

086.jpg
Father Duffy, Times Square. Andre Kertesz, 1937.

087.jpg
Manhattan Bridge from Brooklyn (now DUMBO), Kertesz, 1937.

088.jpg
Henry Hudson Parkway at 72nd St.: fancy interchange. Fairchild Aerial Surveys, 1937.


Simply Add Boiling Water, 1937. Photo by Weegee.

0911.jpg
The old Met(ropolitan Opera), Garment District, 1937. Weegee.

0921.jpg
Still clean and gleaming, the Towers of Zenith, 1937.

Berenice Abbott, 1938

0931.jpg
Duke Mansion, a tobacco tycoon’s, 1 E. 78th St. at Fifth Ave.


40th between 6th and 7th. Zoning generates the form.


Flam & Flam, Lawyers, 165 E. 121st St.

096.jpg
Wall Street from 60 Wall.

098.jpg
Cathedral Parkway (110th Street).

099.jpg
Columbus Circle. Building with Coke sign another of Hearst’s skyscraper bases. Unlike the one Foster is currently completing, this one was torn down for the Gulf and Western Building, now re-imagined by Phillip Johnson as the Trump International Hotel.

100.jpg
Jefferson Market with the hulking, deco Women’s House of Detention behind (now demolished for a park). From the barred, open windows, the ladies would hurl obscenities at passersby.

1011.jpg
504-506 Broome St. Ancient.

1021.jpg
Union Square West. A hilarious jumble gets A+ for accidental design. These lots once held town houses. Their dainty footprints have been preserved, so the buildings have a delicate scale regardless of their height. One is a miniature skyscraper. Scale-obsessed NIMBYs take note: you need to object to a building’s footprint, not its height.

1031.jpg
From Jersey, the classic skyline view.

1041.jpg
Subway Portrait. Walker Evans, 1938.

1051.jpg
Artists and Poets, Washington Sq., 1939

1071.jpg
Clipper, 1939. Europe in 29 hours.

108.jpg
DC-4 Over Midtown, 1939. Hood’s Daily News Building lower right.

109.jpg
Fish market meets railroad under Roebling’s bridge, 1939.

1101.jpg
Abandoned in the downpour, 1939. West Side.

1111.jpg
Forty-second Street.

1131.jpg
Sixth Avenue El, 1940.

1141.jpg
Downtown from Empire State. Andre Kertesz, 1940.

1940 Photos by Andreas Feininger

1151.jpg
Ninth Avenue El, 8th at 127th, Harlem.

1161.jpg
The Bowery.

1181.jpg
Downtown Skyport with Cities Service Tower.

1191.jpg
The original twin towers.

120.jpg
Tower trio. Slender flattop is Irving Trust, tower at right now belongs to Trump.

1211.jpg
New York’s greatest walk.

1221.jpg
Brooklyn and Manhattan Bridges.

1231.jpg
Girlies.

1241.jpg
Downtown gunsmith.

1251.jpg
Three icons: Empire State; Horn and Hardart (The Automat), New York’s original restaurant chain, long gone; lamp standard, now being re-installed.

1261.jpg
Elevated.

1281.jpg
Central Park looking southeast toward Grand Army Plaza. The baronial Savoy-Plaza Hotel dominates with its vast, vaguely French roof and twin chimneys: another major Beaux-Arts landmark demolished mid-sixties. Replaced by Stone’s vapid GM Building, recently acquired by Trump.

129.jpg
Elevated station, Downtown.


Underwear and kosher chickens.

130.jpg
What happens when you burn coal.

1271.jpg
A Greek temple burning coal.

1321.jpg
Flatiron with Fifth Avenue bus.

1331.jpg
Garment District stacked factories steam hats.

1341.jpg
Arm wrestling in Harlem.

1351.jpg
Harlem night club.

1361.jpg
Lower East Side, tenement city, looking north.

1371.jpg
Streetwall: Park Avenue South.

1381.jpg
Raymond Hood, master of Deco.

139.jpg
Seventh Avenue.

140.jpg
South Street, now a theme park and mall.

1411.jpg
At the foot of 42nd Street: Normandie with three fat stacks in the middle, Queen Mary with three skinnier stacks at bottom. Normandie burned here, Nazi sabotage claimed. Normandie was that time’s biggest and fastest (Blue Ribbon).

1941 Photos by Feininger

1441.jpg
Classic skyline view with America, junior edition United States.

1431.jpg
Midtown from Jersey.

1461.jpg
Horror vacui, Hebrew style.

147.jpg
The hats match the canopies. Macy’s, 34th St.

Charles W. Cushman Photos, 1941
A color photographer with a black-and-white soul.

1611.jpg
The classic pyramid, here with harbor traffic and puffs of pollution.

1621.jpg
Suits on the pier. What are these men doing?

1631.jpg
Fulton St. from South St.

1641.jpg
Broome St. and Baruch Pl., Lower East Side. Not a sidewalk café.

165.jpg
Lower East Side: street as living room.

166.jpg
Lower East Side: street as conference room

167.jpg
Municipal Building, Courthouse and Jail. Big arch seemed futile before El removed.
Fairchild Aerial Surveys, 1941.

Charles Cushman photos, 1942.

169.jpg
Lunch, 5 Cents: looking up Broadway to Singer Building.

168.jpg
Collecting the Salvage on Lower East Side.

170.jpg
Pearl Street, 1942.

1721.jpg
Central Park. Feininger, 1943.

1731.jpg
The Fashionable People [harassed by the homeless]. Weegee, 1943.

1741.jpg
Murder in Hell’s Kitchen. Weegee, 1944.

1751.jpg
Coney Island. Weegee, 1945.

176.jpg
The photographer Weegee (Arthur Fellig).

177.jpg
Hole where plane (B-25) hit Empire State Building, 1945.

Andre Kertesz photos

178.jpg
Brooklyn, 1947. Andre Kertesz.

179.jpg
Lower 5th Avenue. Kertesz, 1948.

180.jpg
East River Esplanade. Kertesz, 1948.

1811.jpg
Metropolitan Life and Empire State. Kertesz, 1950.

1821.jpg
City. Kertesz, 1952.

1831.jpg
Skyline with Rooster. Kertesz, 1952.

1841.jpg
Washington Square. Kertesz, 1954.

1851.jpg
A city of spires. Just before the flattop invasion, late fifties.

1861.jpg
First view of Manhattan from the Queen Elizabeth, 1953. The module of the window.

188.jpg
Times Square with James Dean. Dennis Stock, 1955.

189.jpg
Balcony. Kertesz, 1957.

190.jpg
Guggenheim under construction, 1958. Car and building share design philosophy.

1911.jpg
MacDougal Alley. Kertesz,1958.

1921.jpg
Sixth Avenue. Kertesz, 1959.

193.jpg
Man Sleeping. Kertesz, 1960.

194.jpg
Whitehall street from Peter Minuit Plaza near Battery. Cushman, 1960.

Four photos by Kertesz

195.jpg
Rooftop, 1961.

196.jpg
Harlem, 1963.

197.jpg
Washington Square, 1969. Edge of Arch at left.

198.jpg
Washington Square Arch, 1970.

199.jpg
Woody Allen and Cleopatra Jones,1971.

200.jpg
Lying Men, Washington Sq. Kertesz, 1974.

2011.jpg
Kertesz, 1979.

202.jpg
World Trade Center. Dennis Stock, 2001.

* * *

Two Greatest Beaux-Arts Buildings Demolished:

205.jpg
The main waiting room. Groined vaults in coffered stone.

206.jpg
The Baths of Caracalla.

207.jpg
The way to the trains.

208.jpg
Groined vaults in steel and glass.

209.jpg
Seventh Avenue. McKim, Meade and White, architects. 1903-63. The building made it to age 60.

2101.jpg
613 feet!! In 1908!

2111.jpg
Ernest Flagg was the architect.

212.jpg
This building also made it to age 60 [1908-68].

213.jpg
Another five years and they would have preserved it.

214.jpg
French Beaux-Arts.

215.jpg
Vacant and awaiting demolition.

216.jpg
From Broadway.

217.jpg
Queen Elizabeth and skyline. Andre Kertesz, 1958.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Zoning Goddess

Cyburbian
Messages
13,853
Points
39
ablarc, you've entirely outdone yourself, that was a tremendous series of photos. The first of the Woolwoorth building is just amazing. Thanks for the post. I will have to take a second (and third) look to take it all in.
 

The Irish One

Member
Messages
2,267
Points
25
Vegetarian dinner for 10 cents isn't bad! This was a nice look at New York's past. Any idea what the ratio of flat top roofs to tapered roofs is today? 150 to 1, I'm cynical?? From the sky, tapered roofs give an ethereal quality to the city. One of my favorites pics is Hester St., Lower East Side, 1901. Makes me think of Sergio Leone's Once Upon a Time in America, many say it was 4 hours too long.
 

Mud Princess

Cyburbian
Messages
4,896
Points
27
Wow. Just a beautiful series of photographs, many of them classics (I always loved Abbott and Kertesz). It also reminds me why I was so fascinated with New York City at a different time in my life. Thanks.
 

freewaytincan

Cyburbian
Messages
125
Points
6
Mud Princess said:
Wow. Just a beautiful series of photographs, many of them classics (I always loved Abbott and Kertesz). It also reminds me why I was so fascinated with New York City at a different time in my life. Thanks.
Agreed, quite incredible, and it even had three of my favorite photographers.
 

The One

Cyburbian
Messages
8,289
Points
29
Fantastic Images

I can smell the character oozing from many of those photo's :-D

Take a look at Bruce Cratsley's work for modern day examples of black and white New York photo's with modern day twists.

See: Bruce Cratsley: Master of Light and Shadow, 1996 and
Bruce Cratsley : white light, silent shadows, 1998 (Southwest US photo's also)
 

Repo Man

Cyburbian
Messages
2,550
Points
25
Awesome - I am always hunting for cool black and white photographs of Cities, especially DC, Milwaukee, Chicago, and NYC. I downloaded about 90 percent of these.
 

Miles Ignatius

Cyburbian
Messages
368
Points
12
I'll Take Manhattan!

Great and grand stuff! I've got a number of old NYC travel books containing some of these same shots. A photographer by the name of Andreas Feininger did a lot of NY street scene/architectural works that are particularly impressive - when I can get the scanner to cooperate, I'll get them up.

Looking at these shots, I'm reminded that New York is truly our "urban colossus."

Thanks!
 

gct13

Cyburbian
Messages
51
Points
4
Remarkable!



Preparing for the 2004 GOP Convention protestors. (joke :-D )



Midtown, 1931. The tracks lead to Penn Station. Post Office spans tracks, may some day be Penn Station. Fairchild.
The Post Office (in front of Penn Station) looks only half-finished here. It runs the full block from Eighth to Ninth Aves; here it looks to run only half-way to Ninth Ave. (?)



Empire State appears... bare without the anteneas. And no extended fence around the observation deck, did no one jump back then? Bryant Park (upper right) had quite a different layout.



Flatiron with Fifth Avenue bus.
Fifth Ave two-way back in the day? (it's southbound now)



Lower East Side, tenement city, looking north.
At first glance I thought this was taken from Brooklyn, due the space between Metropolitan Life (left) and Empire State; you'd have to look somewhat westward to achieve that perspective (just a guess).
 

ablarc

Cyburbian Emeritus
Messages
713
Points
20
"At first glance I thought this was taken from Brooklyn, due the space between Metropolitan Life (left) and Empire State; you'd have to look somewhat westward to achieve that perspective (just a guess)."

Manhattan bows out into the East River between the Brooklyn and Manhattan bridges. All those buildings in the foreground and midground are gone now, replace by x-shaped buildings in a "park": a Ville Radieuse: Governor Alfred E. Smith Houses, 1952.
 

chezchas

Member
Messages
1
Points
0
Problems with some of the photos

This is a beautiful set of photographs -- I really enjoyed browsing through them after having just seen "Hester Street."

Some of the photos did not load properly (the bottom have of the photo is gray). For example, see the photo titled "Tiffany’s, Union Sq."

I'm pretty sure this is not a problem just with my computer since I tried dowloading several times (after clearing my browser cache), and the problems always recurred with the same photos.

Is there a chance they have become corrupted on the server?

If possible, could they be uploaded again to the server?

If necessary, I could list each affected photo, but I think it will be evident which ones are having problems.

I really enjoyed these photos and would love to see the complete set!

Thanks, ablarc for posting these -- they are a treasure!
 

tsc

Cyburbian
Messages
1,905
Points
23
Thanks a million...love this series. I am lucky I have a couple meetings a month in Manhattan... so I get to get out of the burbs from time to time and into the city.
 

evannostrand

Member
Messages
1
Points
0
National City Building?

Amazing, Depressing, Inspiring set of pictures. I never tire of looking at the way it was. The money, (billions of dollars cumulative!?!) Imagination, Craftsmanship, the man hours, labor and love that went into creating these magnificent structures that were so easily discarded like yesterday's trash, for what? I was one when Penn went, and seven when the Singer building went, and though I'm from New York I never set foot in either one, and for that I am saddened. Luckily I visited the WTC just months before, not realizing it would be my first and only time to view New York from the top of the World in lower Manhattan. (I love the ESB but the view just isn't the same). THAT was inspiring, even now, years later and many miles away.

I do have a question,

Does anyone know anything about this building (A Greek temple burning coal), when it was built, for whom, demolished when and replaced by?

http://66.230.220.70/images/post/nycbw/127.jpg


I believe it is the National City Building by McKim, Mead and White. I think it was replaced by 60 Wall St, J P Morgan/Deutsche Bank Building in the late 80's, but there is NOTHING to be found about it. I see it in so many pictures of old, but it's never captioned, always taking a back seat to the taller and grander buildings surrounding it. That Greek Temple at the top has always intrigued me. I never get to see the base of the building and really wonder what it looks like up close. Thanks!
 

BillyBlastoff

Member
Messages
1
Points
0
I'm not seeing

I'm not seeing any pictures. :-c I'm working on a project for my Mom who turns 70 on Monday. I sure would like to include some of those picks.
 

jsk1983

Cyburbian
Messages
2,442
Points
23
I'm not seeing any pictures. :-c I'm working on a project for my Mom who turns 70 on Monday. I sure would like to include some of those picks.
I think your out of luck. The original poster is no longer an acitve member. I'm sure there are plenty of similar photos out there though.
 

Barney

Member
Messages
2
Points
0
Hi, I just joined and i love B/W photos of NYC, i used to live there many , many years ago... to many to count ;-)

Anyway, i can't seem to get the images to come up on this page :(

Am i doing anything wrong?

Thank you... :)
 

jsk1983

Cyburbian
Messages
2,442
Points
23
Hi, I just joined and i love B/W photos of NYC, i used to live there many , many years ago... to many to count ;-)

Anyway, i can't seem to get the images to come up on this page :(

Am i doing anything wrong?

Thank you... :)
No... the original post is over three years old. Depending on where the photos are hosted, they sometimes disapear after awhile. The original poster is no longer active on this site so I'm afraid you out of luck.:-(
 

Dan

Dear Leader
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
17,755
Points
58
Moderator note:

Apparently, the photos were included in a thread on a forum where ablarc remains a frequent poster. That thread got over 430,000 views, killing his bandwidth. The photos in other ablarc threads remain.
 

MOTHERSHIP

Member
Messages
2
Points
0
BEAUTIFUL PHOTOS

As a lifelong New Yorker, and a lover of the past and history. It was nice to see what NYC looked like back then. If anyone has any old photos of Harlem it would be nice to see. I'm 51 and most of the buildings were being torn down when I was a kid. I was born on 120th & Madison Avenue in one of those classic buildings. It's torn down now. A big nasty building is in it's place. 1831 Madison Avenue. There were brownstones all up and down Madison and especially across from Mt.Morris Park which is now Marcus Garvey. I can't understand why people can't respect the past or landmarks. Also, a lot of famous folks were born in that area as well.
 

Peity

Member
Messages
10
Points
1
What a fabulous photo collection - my favorite is the shot with the Navy blimp---looks surreal. All wonderful and dramatic with stark beauty (I love black and white!) .


________________________________________

I :) Broadway Shows
 

Linda_D

Cyburbian
Messages
1,725
Points
19
Big thumbs up on a great photo collection! Being a history buff, I just love this stuff!
 

Dan

Dear Leader
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
17,755
Points
58
Moderator note:

The images in this thread are now hosted in the Cyburbia Gallery. See http://www.cyburbia.org/gallery/showgallery.php/cat/6529 . It took a while to rebuild this very popular thread, and it's going to suck up a lot of bandwidth in the future, but given that Ablarc has been hosting the images in the past to our benefit, it's our turn to host them now..
 
Top