• Ongoing coronavirus / COVID-19 discussion: how is the pandemic affecting your community, workplace, and wellness? 🦠

    Working from home? So are we. Come join us! Cyburbia is a friendly big tent, where we share our experiences and thoughts about urban planning practice, planning adjacent topics, and whatever else comes to mind. No ads, no spam, no social distancing.

Take one great movie - cut out one bad scene.

Super Amputee Cat

Cyburbian
Messages
2,238
Points
30
I’m sure that almost all of us have a favorite movie that has at least one scene that we would like to have edited out. This is especially true after repeated viewings, where we can’t wait for the scene to be over and get on with the great parts of the film.

There have been many movies that I have rated *** ½ stars that have one or two scenes that kept them from being perfect. While the film was still highly recommendable, one wonders what the producers were ultimately thinking by allowing a particular scene to survive the final edit.

SPOILER WARNING!

My pick would be the movie Fearless with Jeff Bridges. A truly remarkable and landmark film about a man who survives a plane crash and for the next few weeks walks around in an almost dreamlike state, thinking he is suddenly immune to everything. He takes crazy chances such as standing on edges of skyscrapers and eating foods that he is allergic too. The film has one of the most unforgettable plane crash sequences ever filmed. A drawn-out, almost surrealistic, sequence – without any explosions or actual crash - that drives home the horror of such an event unlike anything ever seen before on film.

This film would have easily been my #1 film of the 1990s except for one scene: The very ending. If you saw the film you will recall that the Bridges’ character eats a strawberry – that he is deathly allergic too – and starts choking immediately. As his wife is frantically trying to revive him, we cut to a scene of him walking away through a tunnel of light – presumably indicating that he is dying. These two scenes cut back and forth, with his wife hysterically screaming out his name, until he magically wakes up and spits out the strawberry.

This ending was too “Hollywood” for me. How much more appropriate it would have been for the final scene to have him continue walking toward the shaft of light while his wife desparetly, but unsuccessfully, tries to revive him.

I would love to buy the rights to this film and cut out the 30 seconds or so.

So, what scene, of what movie, would you like to edit out or change and why?
 

otterpop

Cyburbian
Messages
6,655
Points
28
"The Searchers" - one of the best Westerns ever made and the Duke's best performance - has one flaw. It isn't one scene. It is two or more scenes involving the Duke's son Patrick as a shavetail calvary officer. This cartoonish performance, much of it playing against Ward Bond's preacher/Texas Ranger character, is inappropriate for this dark, character-driven story. This is a flaw of John Ford's Westerns. He always seems to cast some young man inappropriately who sticks out like a sore thumb and detracts from the story. It is bad enough in his lesser picutres, but "The Searchers" was too fine a story and picture to muddle up.
 

Super Amputee Cat

Cyburbian
Messages
2,238
Points
30
Here's another one: Roger and Me

This was one of the greatest "documentaries" at all time - the film the really put Michael Moore on the map. His swipes at corporate America are even more relavent today in this currupt post-Enron world.

However, I didn't like the scene where they killed the rabbit. Here they have this cute fuzzy rabbit and the lady just smashes it in the head. (My wife made me fast foward this scene when we watched it one video). Then they show the rabbit being skinned.
 

mendelman

Unfrozen Caveman Planner
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
13,891
Points
56
Super Amputee Cat said:
Here's another one: Roger and Me

However, I didn't like the scene where they killed the rabbit. Here they have this cute fuzzy rabbit and the lady just smashes it in the head. (My wife made me fast foward this scene when we watched it one video). Then they show the rabbit being skinned.
Off-topic:
That scene was necessary as a counterpoint with the scene where the black man was shot by police. Anyway, she was doing it to feed herself. You are applying too much late twentith century appropriatness(sp?) to the act.
 

Super Amputee Cat

Cyburbian
Messages
2,238
Points
30
mendelman said:
Off-topic:
That scene was necessary as a counterpoint with the scene where the black man was shot by police. Anyway, she was doing it to feed herself. You are applying too much late twentith century appropriatness(sp?) to the act.

I understand that she had to feed herself, it's just the graphic nature of the scene that disturbed me, especially since she was holding and petting it just before.
 

mendelman

Unfrozen Caveman Planner
Staff member
Moderator
Messages
13,891
Points
56
Super Amputee Cat said:
I understand that she had to feed herself, it's just the graphic nature of the scene that disturbed me, especially since she was holding and petting it just before.
And a man being shot on a public street is not graphic?

Moore was using a narrative device to make a point. Yes, she was treating it as if it was a pet, but would you rather eat your pet dog or starve?

Edit: Plus she seemed to be self-sufficient and not relying on handouts, which probably showed her strength in hard times.
 

SkeLeton

Cyburbian
Messages
4,853
Points
26
Matrix Reloaded...

The scene to cut... the friggin party in Zion... I mean.. COME ON! Couldn't it be a little more boring and long?!?!?! The only reason I didn't fall asleep during that scene, is because of the horrible thumping of the electronic music...

The rest is quite good...
 
Messages
130
Points
6
mendelman said:
Off-topic:
That scene was necessary as a counterpoint with the scene where the black man was shot by police. Anyway, she was doing it to feed herself. You are applying too much late twentith century appropriatness(sp?) to the act.
I thought it was a commentary on how GM treated Flint, MI.
 

Rumpy Tunanator

Cyburbian
Messages
4,473
Points
25
How about worst scenes put into a classic movie. I can think of all the crap George Lucas put into the Star Wars remakes that just desecrate the originals. Then there's Spielberg who ruined E.T.
 

Chet

Cyburbian Emeritus
Messages
10,623
Points
34
The ending scene of the Abyss then the giant UFO rises out of the depths. Good movie, stooopid ending.
 

ludes98

Cyburbian
Messages
1,264
Points
22
Chet- Have you seen the Abyss director's cut of the film with the additional "alien" scenes? Lends some sense to the ending. Doesn't make it a better movie, just adds understanding.
 

SGB

Cyburbian
Messages
3,388
Points
26
Chet said:
The ending scene of the Abyss then the giant UFO rises out of the depths. Good movie, stooopid ending.
About half the audience in the cinema I saw that film (including me) in were pissed about that ending. What a disappointment!
 

el Guapo

Capitalist
Messages
5,995
Points
31
SkeLeton said:
Matrix Reloaded...

The scene to cut... the friggin party in Zion... I mean.. COME ON! Couldn't it be a little more boring and long?!?!?! The only reason I didn't fall asleep during that scene, is because of the horrible thumping of the electronic music...

The rest is quite good...
Agreed! Well the bouncing held my attention for a few minutes
 

Super Amputee Cat

Cyburbian
Messages
2,238
Points
30
SGB said:
About half the audience in the cinema I saw that film (including me) in were pissed about that ending. What a disappointment!
You guys definately need to see the director's cut. It's a totally different movie in my opinion. It adds context to the alien scenes in the original theatrical version which make a whole lot more sense.
 
Top